Last week, the Senate of the Parliament of Kazakhstan considered amendments to legislation regulating, among other things, lending to individuals. The Agency of the Republic of Kazakhstan for Regulation and Development of the Financial Market is concerned about individuals’ overdue debts to microfinance organizations. Yet about 89% of the loans transferred to collectors belong to banks. Who benefits from the ARDFM’s fight against a non-existent shadow?!
Recently, the financial portal LS, citing the ARDFM, reported that as of April 1, banks and MFOs had transferred 915 thousand contracts worth 444 billion tenge to collectors. Of the total debt, about 89%, or 395 billion tenge, consists of obligations to banks; 5%, or 24 billion tenge, to microfinance organizations; and 6%, or 25 billion tenge, to other organizations.
At the same time, according to the National Bank, as of May 1, overdue debt on bank loans amounted to 631.3 billion tenge. The largest debt falls on the non-productive sector and individual activities – 390 billion tenge. This is followed by wholesale and retail trade, where this figure decreased by 43.6% to 93.2 billion tenge.
It is worth noting that consumer lending remains the main driver of retail lending. At the same time, the growth rate of the consumer loan portfolio slowed to 35.6% in April compared to 37.9% in January, while the annual growth of mortgage loans accelerated to 49.8%.
Despite the outward well-being, the ARDFM is tightening borrowing conditions. For example, the current version of the Law on Microfinance Activities provides for special conditions for issuing a microloan to an individual in an amount of up to 50 MCI and for a term of up to 45 days. For instance, the maximum interest on a microloan and the amount of penalties are limited.
Madina Abylkasymova presented a draft law on the development of the insurance market, the securities market and banking activities
“In order to reduce the debt burden of borrowers of microfinance organizations, it is proposed to limit borrowers’ debt burden by halving the amount of overpayment on a microloan – from 100% to 50% of the microloan amount,” Madina Abylkasymova, Chair of the ARDFM, said in Parliament.
“We consider these measures very timely and necessary. At the same time, in our opinion, in order not to throw the baby out with the bathwater, it is also necessary to ensure a balance between the interests of borrowers and lenders. Speaking at the VI meeting of the National Council of Public Trust, the Head of State Kassym-Jomart Kemelevich Tokayev noted: ‘It is necessary to take balanced measures to support borrowers without harming the financial sector.’ Harsh excesses in consumer lending may threaten to expand the sphere of illegal lenders, swindlers and fraudsters, since the population’s need for credit resources is difficult to regulate with prohibitive measures,” comments Yerbol Omarhanov, Chairman of the Association of Legal Entities “Association of Microfinance Organizations of Kazakhstan” (AMFOK).
According to AMFOK, up to 80% of MFO loans in Kazakhstan are issued for business purposes rather than consumer ones.
“Slightly more than 2 million citizens of our country belong to the self-employed part of the population without officially confirmed income. This means that such citizens will no longer be able to obtain loans from official credit organizations, which may be exploited by shadow lenders who are already offering their services. The consequences of this could be much more serious,” the interviewee emphasizes.
Banks have already responded, and according to a survey by the National Bank of Kazakhstan, financiers have tightened requirements in the unsecured and secured lending segments. Moreover, “banks have begun to revise the threshold values of product scoring models.”
“I do not think we have a problem of over-indebtedness of the population; we have a problem of low incomes. Until people have enough money for a decent life, they will always take out loans and live in debt. And if the regulator makes access to borrowed resources in banks more difficult, people will move into the informal sphere, and so-called loan sharks will flourish,” the interviewee explains.
“Loan sharks” is a term applied to shadow moneylenders who issue loans at very high interest rates without having a license from the regulator. Such lenders often operate from home or online and do not provide the documents needed to confirm the agreement concluded with them.
Recently, regulators, the police and private financial institutions have increasingly warned Kazakhstanis about fraudulent loan-related schemes. Of course, there is no direct evidence that the ARDFM’s tightening is linked to a sharp surge in fraudsters’ activity. But today, because of fraudsters, trusting people lose their last savings instead of getting a loan.
How can you recognize a fake lender? There are several characteristic features.
Fake license. Fraudsters post a supposed copy of a license on their website so that you trust them. But when checking with the regulator, you will either not find such a credit organization or discover that the number belongs to another financial institution.
Suspicious name. The name of a fraudulent website may be very similar to the name of a real bank or MFO. They may copy the logos and design of well-known bank or MFO websites.
No reporting. You are unlikely to find on the website the public information about the organization’s activities that banks are required to publish on their websites: constituent documents, financial statements, rating assessments.
And one more thing: most often, fake banks have no legal entity or any legal form at all. This means that tracking down the fraudsters will be practically impossible.
The history of consumer credit is a fairly young area of banking business in our country. That is why financiers are doing many things for the first time. The ARDFM decided not to study the successful experience of consumer lending in the US and the EU, but simply to tighten borrowing conditions for ordinary people as much as possible.
Irina LEDOVSKIKH